Chapter 70: Didn’t You Humiliate Charlie? 
“Vivi?” 

Samuel sneered. He coldly looked at Lily, “I knew you went to see Vivi! Lily, however you put it, Vivi is your daughter, what have you done to her? How could you let Charlie vent his anger on the Mirren family!?” 
“What did I do to Vivi?” 
Lily looked confused, “I didn’t do anything to Vivi.” 
“Hmm…” 
Sitting next to his father, Daniel Mirren also sneered, “Ms. Dench, I handed over a contract yesterday which should have been returned today. But just now, Tom told me that Charlie has canceled this cooperation with the Mirren family. The two ongoing projects are also suspended. After you visited Vivian, the Firth family suddenly gets so mad at us. Tell me, if it’s not because of something you did to Vivi, what else could it be?” 
“…” 
Lily was about to retort, but she suddenly remembered the “Vivian” on Charlie’s side was Nancy! 
She had secretly arranged the marriage for Nancy to replace Vivian. She never let anyone from the Mirren family know. 
Her face alternated in anger and anxiety, but she couldn’t say a word. She was obviously guilty. 
Even though Samuel usually spoiled her, that didn’t extend to situations. involving gains and losses. But the relationship between the Mirren family and the Firth family turned bad, it was a huge loss for them. Even if he loved Lily, he couldn’t tolerate such a thing happening. 
“Say it!” 
Samuel kicked Lily in the leg and roared, “Tell us, what did you do to Vivi?” 
Lily was kicked to the ground. In all her years of marriage to Samuel, this was the first time he had injured her and she dared not argue. 
Chapter 70: Didn’t You Humate Charlie? 
212 
In an instant, she broke into tears. Sitting on the floor, she hugged her legs, then replied with a crying tone, “I didn’t do anything to her. I j–just argued with 
her…” 
Daniel snorted, “Ms. Dench, you better not downplay the situation here. I heard that Vivi was drenched in the rain when she left? And she’s even wounded?” 
As he said that, he looked more disdainful, “Vivi is indeed your daughter, but now she is Mrs. Firth. You didn’t beat your daughter. You beat Mrs. Firth. When you beat Mrs. Firth, didn’t you humiliate Charlie?” 
Lily didn’t think about it at all when she beat Nancy! 
She was so frightened that her body trembled. She raised her head to look at Samuel with a pitiful expression, “Samuel, what should I do now? I…” 
“What else can you do?” 
Samuel walked over and slapped Lily twice across the face. 
“I can only leave some scars on your face, then take you to apologize to Charlie! 
After that, he slapped Lily twice more across the face. 
Daniel watched coldly, then added, Hopefully Charlie will forgive you when he sees your face, otherwise our family is doomed.” 
Hearing that, Samuel’s hits grew even harder. 
At first, he just wanted to slap Lily a few times, just for show. But what if it wasn’t enough? 
He had to slap her for real, and beat her hard…